Red Flags in Marketing Job Descriptions: Why Unrealistic Expectations Lead to High Turnover

If you’ve been browsing job boards lately, you’ve probably noticed a pattern: many marketing job descriptions read like a wish list of every possible skill. Founders often expect one marketer to be a brand strategist, content writer, graphic designer, SEO expert, media buyer, CRM admin, and event planner — all rolled into one.

This is especially common when startups hire their first marketing lead. The intention is good: they want to set up marketing properly. But when expectations are unrealistic, it leads to burnout, frustration, and ultimately, high turnover.

As seasoned marketers, we’ve seen this play out too often. Here’s why it happens, and how to set a more realistic plan that keeps both founders and marketers aligned.

The Red Alert: Long Lists of Responsibilities

When a marketing job description reads like 10 different roles in one, that’s a red flag. A few warning signs include:

• “Own everything end-to-end” with no clarity on priorities.
• A list of 20+ responsibilities spanning every channel imaginable.
• High growth expectations with no budget or tools allocated.
• No mention of KPIs or success metrics, just “drive results.”

These types of job postings set candidates up for failure. One person cannot realistically build an entire marketing engine overnight.

Why This Happens in Startups

When founders hire their first marketer, the goal is often to maximise impact right away. They want one person to drive brand awareness, generate leads, support sales, and even build a community. It’s understandable — startups usually operate with limited budgets and expect their first marketing hire to be highly hands-on. The challenge is that many underestimate:

• The time it takes to build foundations (branding, content, CRM).
• The sequencing of priorities (brand first, then lead gen, then campaigns).
• The resources required (budget for tools, ads, or design).
  

The Solution: Set Realistic KPIs with a Timeline

Instead of a never-ending checklist, break down marketing into phases with achievable KPIs. This gives the marketer room to succeed, and the company a clear way to measure progress.

Here’s a sample realistic timeline for a first marketing hire in a startup or SME:

Months 1–3: Foundation Building

Focus: Set up systems and establish brand basics.

KPIs:

• Develop brand messaging and visual identity.
• Build marketing tech stack (CRM, email, analytics).
• Launch company LinkedIn and website blog.
• Publish 2–4 pieces of core content (e.g., company intro, customer stories).

Months 4–6: Awareness and Early Demand

Focus: Grow visibility and start generating leads.

KPIs:

• Increase social media followers by 20–30%.
• Launch first email campaign or newsletter.
• Run 1–2 small paid campaigns to test channels.
• Generate first batch of MQLs (Marketing Qualified Leads).

Months 7–9: Lead Nurturing and Optimization

Focus: Scale efforts and refine messaging.

KPIs:

• Achieve consistent lead flow (e.g., 10–20 MQLs/month).
• Set up lead scoring and nurturing workflows in CRM.
• Launch case study or customer testimonial campaign.
• Improve website traffic by 30–40% from baseline.

Months 10–12: Scale and Align with Sales

Focus: Integrate marketing deeper into revenue goals.

KPIs:

• Deliver a predictable pipeline contribution (e.g., 25% of sales pipeline from marketing).
• Partner with SDR/BDR team for aligned outreach campaigns.
• Launch 1–2 larger integrated campaigns (webinar, industry event, or content series).
• Track and report CAC (Customer Acquisition Cost) and ROI by channel.

Why This Approach Works

By breaking the role into phases with realistic KPIs:

• Founders get visibility into progress without unrealistic expectations.
• Marketers know what success looks like and can build step by step.
• The business reduces turnover by creating achievable goals and celebrating milestones.

Final Thoughts

Hiring an experienced marketer is one of the smartest investments a founder can make. But it’s important to remember: marketing is a long game, not an overnight miracle.

Set expectations too high, and you risk losing good talent. Set them realistically — with clear KPIs and timelines — and you’ll not only retain your marketer, you’ll build a sustainable growth engine.

At Fractional Marketer, we help founders design these roadmaps so they can avoid common pitfalls and set their first hires up for success.

Thinking about hiring your first marketer? Let’s talk about how to set the right KPIs and build a realistic growth plan.

Let's chat!